Working Girls (1986)

By treating sex work as just another form of labour, Borden strips away the usual sensationalism to reveal the routines, compromises and workplace dynamics beneath, crafting a refreshingly matter-of-fact and quietly radical film.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Review #3,108

Dir. Lizzie Borden
1986 | USA | Drama | 93min | 1.66:1 | English
Not rated – likely to be R21 for sexual scenes, mature themes and coarse language

Cast: Ellen McElduff, Amanda Goodwin, Marusia Zach, Janne Peters, Helen Nicholas
Plot: A lesbian college graduate, trying to bankroll her own photography business, works as a high-priced New York City escort.
Awards: Won Special Jury Recognition & Nom. for Grand Jury Prize – Dramatic (Sundance)
Source:
UCLA Film & Television Archive

Accessibility Index
Subject Matter: Mature – Sex Workers; Workplace Dynamics
Narrative Style: Straightforward

Pace: Slightly Slow
Audience Type: Slightly Arthouse

Viewed: MUBI
Spoilers: No


Molly is a college graduate. She’s hoping to earn enough money to give her photography business idea a go.  She’s intelligent, so she won’t sell her mind; but she’s also pragmatic, and doesn’t mind selling her body to make the kind of quick bucks that allow her to anticipate a more promising future. 

She’s a lesbian, so having sex with random guys as a “working girl” has some kind of counteracting appeal—after all, there is hardly any attraction, lots of faking of sexual pleasure, and at the end of the day, hopefully a sizable paycheck to bring home.

Isn’t that also the kind of work many of us are doing, or “aspire” to do, outside of our passions—the monotonous labour for someone, some company, some government with which we may have little emotional affinity? 

Director Lizzie Borden has concocted something quite special in Working Girls, a follow-up to the more radical Born in Flames (1984). But one shouldn’t mistake this more laissez-faire drama for anything less compelling or revelatory.

Sex work, and sex workers, have long been depicted in fiction cinema as a social vice or moral taboo, or degraded and sensationalised through genre filmmaking, particularly crime pictures rife with sexual violence and gratuitous nudity.

“Sometimes I just can’t believe I’m doing this.”

Here, Borden treats sex work like office work: the drudgery of admin meetings, the calculative-ness of finance, the PR-ness of client servicing, the performativity of various job scopes, a naggy, pro-OT boss, and the love-hate relationships with colleagues. 

She also treats sex and nudity with zero sensuality—taking off one’s clothes is no different from sending an email (there was no corporate emailing back then in the mid-‘80s, but you get the point).

The entire film is cocooned mostly in the interiors of the working space that Molly and her colleagues occupy during their shifts, with the light techno-style music scoring punctuated frequently by an incessant ringing phone (biz must be very good!).

Thanks to the naturalness of the performances, Working Girls occasionally feels like a documentary, as though a camera had been placed unobtrusively to capture the raw authenticity of it all. Yet we never feel as though we’re spying on them. The male-gaze voyeurism typically associated with this subject matter is conspicuously absent. Borden’s film is truly an experience unlike any other.

Grade: A-


Trailer:

One Comment

Leave a Reply